Review - X-Men/Avengers: Onslaught Omnibus

The greatest evil that Earth’s heroes may ever face has appeared. With the psychic powers of Professor Xavier and the maniacal motivations of Magneto, the entity known as Onslaught has dedicated itself to the eradication of all humans on the planet. Only the combined might of the Avengers, Fantastic Four, and the X-Men may be able to stop it.

X-Men/Avengers: Onslaught Omnibus collects Cable #32-36, Uncanny X-Men #333-337, X-Force #55, 57-58, X-Man #15-19, X-Men #53-57, Annual '96, X-Men Unlimited #11, Onslaught: X-Men, Marvel Universe, Epilogue, Avengers #401-402, Fantastic Four #415, Incredible Hulk #444-445, Wolverine #104-105, X-Factor #125-126, Amazing Spider-Man #415, Green Goblin #12, Spider-Man #72, Iron Man #332, Punisher #11, Thor #502, X-Men: Road to Onslaught, and material from Excalibur #100 and Fantastic Four #416. It includes work by Scott Lobdell, Jeph Loeb, Mark Waid, Terry Kavanagh, Andy Kubert, Ian Churchill, Joe Madureira, and Adam Kubert.

Onslaught is an “epic” that began building in the aftermath of the X-Men crossover Fatal Attractions. After Professor Xavier psionically erases Magneto’s mind, his guilt over his actions and the presence of his rival’s psyche in his unconscious leads to the creation of Onslaught. This entity draws its powers from both Xavier and Magneto. It attacks the X-Men, kidnaps Franklin Richards and Nate Grey, and unleashes Sentinels onto New York City. Upon recovering from their initial battle against Onslaught, the X-Men join forces with the Avengers and the Fantastic Four to prevent the total annihilation of humans. From a conceptual point of view, this makes for an absolutely thrilling premise and works to throw all of the Marvel Universe’s greatest heroes together in one epic showdown against a powerful foe. Unfortunately, the execution is so poor that it makes this crossover incredibly tedious to sit through.

This omnibus is incredibly dense and combines every possible issue related to Onslaught in one giant hardcover. The problem with that is that it means there are so many subplots and tie-ins that it distracts from the primary narrative. The main plot of this crossover occurs in the pages of the main X-Men books, Avengers, and Fantastic Four. Those issues are actually very engaging and provide readers with the emotional core of this storyline. Namely, we see the X-Men struggling with their beloved mentor potentially being the greatest evil the world has ever known and Invisible Woman fighting to get her son back after Onslaught takes him. The problem is that the inclusion of the various tie-ins distracts from this and requires readers to slog through random issues where it’s Spider-Man randomly fighting Sentinels or Cable duking it out with the Hulk while the latter is under the control of Onslaught. Personally, I’d have preferred more editing when this omnibus was put together in order to trim the filler material or to at least structure things better so the inferior material is placed at the back as supplemental reading.

Much of the variance in quality comes from the sheer number of creators working on this crossover. There are a total of 11 writers who receive credit, 26 artists, 31 inkers, and 23 colorists. This creates a lot of room for inconsistencies. The strongest issues are those penned by Scott Lobdell and Mark Waid, with art by Andy Kubert and Joe Madureira. Those are the most dynamic and straightforward. In fact, Madureira is arguably the star of this entire collection. His work is so different from the others that it naturally stands out and the anime-inspired aesthetic is as bold as it is expressive. There’s also an issue of Cable by Jeph Loeb and Ian Churchill that’s quite good, which features Cable and Invisible Woman forging an uneasy alliance with Apocalypse in hopes of undermining Onslaught’s schemes. Churchill’s work is always really spectacular. It’s vibrant and emotive in a way that most of the artists’ work in this omnibus is not.

X-Men/Avengers: Onslaught Omnibus requires a lot of patience. It’s not a streamlined crossover that has a general through line. It’s messy and it’s long. Given that it’s one of Marvel’s earliest attempts at a company-wide crossover, it’s understandable as to why it is as mediocre as it is. Unlike future events that would be contained within mini- or maxi-series, this one is spread out over just about every Marvel comic imaginable from this era and its structuring lacks direction. There’s no part one, two, three, and so on. Some of the issues collected in this edition are enjoyable. There’s a lot of gorgeous art to be found and some interesting character development, especially for the X-Men. Sadly, it’s buried within unevenness. As a concept, Onslaught is brilliant and is something I’d love to see tackled again (though not in the main Marvel universe) as a way of making up for the original’s shortcomings. As it is, the Onslaught Omnibus may not be a purchase I’d recommend unless you’re a true completionist.

RATING: C-

Review - Ultimate Fantastic Four Volume 1: The Fantastic

For years, science prodigy Reed Richards has tried to unlock the secrets of the alternate dimension known as the N-Zone. Now with his best friend Ben Grimm and his colleagues at the Baxter Building by his side, he’s ready to make his first large scale attempt to break into the N-Zone. The experiment goes predictably awry, granting the team with strange abilities and leaving its most vulnerable member at the mercy of a disgruntled former employee of the Baxter Building.

Ultimate Fantastic Four Volume 1: The Fantastic collects Ultimate Fantastic Four #1-6, written by Brian Michael Bendis and Mark Millar and illustrated by Adam Kubert.

The Fantastic is a six issue expansion and re-imagining of the Fantastic Four’s iconic origins. The cosmic rays and space elements are out, with our intrepid quartet instead acquiring their abilities as a result of a teleportation experiment connecting them to the N-Zone. It leaves them scattered across the globe, alone in trying to figure out what has just happened to them. Susan Storm awakes to find herself in the clutches of Dr. Molevic (AKA Mole Man) deep beneath New York City in the sewer system. She must bide her time while the others search for her. For the most part, this revision of their origins still stays true to the essence and narrative aspects of the original. They even fight a giant monster in their first major battle. Much like with Ultimate Spider-Man, this story takes what was originally a one-and-done and teases it out over six issues. This offers writers Brian Michael Bendis and Mark Millar the opportunity to develop the characters. Reed in particular gets a rather in-depth backstory. However, this prolongs the assembly of the Fantastic Four and it results in several lacklustre issues that have virtually no action.

I’m fairly split on how I feel about this arc. There are pieces of it that I enjoy – namely the revamping of the Baxter Building as the HQ to the government-funded think tank for young geniuses and the decision to portray Sue as a scientist. Tonally, Ultimate Fantastic Four gets off to the right start by maintaining a nice balance between humour and drama. With that said, Bendis and Millar linger too long on Reed. The other three characters get virtually no development in comparison and seem pretty disposable until they get their powers. The problem here is that it takes roughly three issues for them to get those powers and even then they don’t get thrown into action right away. We have to spend time watching Johnny how to control his abilities and seeing Ben agonize over his physical transformation. This wouldn’t be such a big deal had they acquired their powers earlier and become a team mid-way through. Instead, what we get is a total slog. (As an aside, I’m also not a fan of Sue being sidelined and effectively filling the role of Damsel in Distress until nearly the very end of the bloody arc)

The art that Adam Kubert provides seems rushed and barely recognizable. When it comes to Kubert’s style, I’ve long felt the faces he draws have a distinctive quality to them. They are part of what makes his work unique. However, the pencils present here lack that quality. Everything appears pretty generic and it brings down the overall aesthetic appeal. Still, there are some impressive artistic moments scattered throughout. There are a lot of splash pages and double-page spreads, particularly as the arc goes on. These help to provide a larger scale to the action and give the book a more cinematic appearance.

Ultimate Fantastic Four Volume 1: The Fantastic is a perfect example of how tricky origin stories can be. As important as they are, these types of narratives are often less exciting than those that flow out of them. Too much time is spent setting up these characters and giving us background information. The Fantastic could have been a great three issue arc. As it is, it leaves a lot to be desired. Regardless, the foundation is pretty solid for this book and is at least given a pretty fresh start to what could be a very modern take on Marvel’s iconic quartet.

RATING: C+