Saturday 15 October 2016

Review: Ultimate X-Men Volume 1 - The Tomorrow People


With the mutant hunting Sentinels and the extremist agenda of mutant supremacist Magneto threatening to ignite a world war, Professor Xavier enlists the help of six young mutants to keep the peace and promote his integrationist beliefs. Though the world may fear and hate them, the X-Men must overcome this and learn to use their unique abilities as a team in order to save the world from total destruction.

Ultimate X-Men Volume 1: The Tomorrow People collects Ultimate X-Men #1-6, written by Mark Millar and illustrated by Adam Kubert.


From its very first few panels, Ultimate X-Men paints a far darker and direr picture of the world than Brian Michael Bendis and Mark Bagley’s Ultimate Spider-Man. Mark Millar and artist Adam Kubert mine the darker impulses of 21st century America by examining the increasingly relevant themes of discrimination and extremism. They focus on the allegory of mutants as minorities with unrelenting precision, exposing how very little we’ve come in terms of acceptance of those who are different from the accepted norm. The Tomorrow People introduces the X-Men as young, inexperienced mutants who are thrust into the roles of heroes without much training. They’re disenfranchised outcasts who society has cast aside. In this respect, it makes it easy to relate to and root for these characters.


The X-Men face the dual threat of the Sentinels and the Brotherhood of Mutants. Their first assignment as a team requires them to retrieve a mutant in the heart of New York City before he can be incinerated by the Sentinels. Naturally, the mission goes sideways and the X-Men are forced into a direct conflict with the Sentinels. It’s an exciting high octane way to initiate the team and showcase their individual abilities, as well as their shortcomings. Millar and Kubert also smartly include a scene in which the X-Men are jeered at after saving innocents from the mayhem, which helps to further emphasize the senseless discrimination mutants (i.e. people of colour and the LGBTQ+) face in this world. However, perceptions towards them shift after they save the President’s daughter from the clutches of the Brotherhood of Mutants and when they successfully defeat Magneto in an all-out fight to the finish in Washington, D.C.


The Tomorrow People is probably the strongest introductory storylines the X-Men have had across any comic book incarnation or adaptation. Millar introduces his cast with ease and establishes the central themes to the X-Men mythos in a way that feels modern and relevant. He excels at pacing and plotting, as he forges a very cohesive and evenly paced storyline that ticks all the necessary boxes to make this a good X-Men story. His very literal portrayal of Magneto and the Brotherhood of Mutants is chilling (but necessary) due to how closely it mirrors modern day terrorists. What is especially eerie about this is that The Tomorrow People feels very much like a Post-9/11 text, but much of it was written and published prior to those events. Where he’s less successful is in his characterizations of the X-Men themselves. Without question, Jean Grey is his most well-written character here. She’s kind and sympathetic, but also sassy and strong-willed. Jean is also a force to be reckoned with on the field and really shows off her skills as a field leader. I’m far less impressed with Millar’s portrayal of Storm. The decisions he makes with her character are problematic as she feels like an entirely different person in comparison to every other version we’ve ever seen. She lacks the confidence and willpower that is a trademark of the character, as well as her warmth and wisdom. Millar instead portrays Storm as a hot mess and a bit of a brat who is quite possibly the team’s biggest liability in the field. There’s also some awkwardness regarding Millar’s decision to have Wolverine (whose age is undisclosed, but we can only imagine is much older than the rest of the X-Men) seduce and sleep with Jean Grey (who is only 19). Additionally, Professor Xavier is nowhere close to being the pacifist we would expect him to be. He uses his powers without discretion and permission of others, while his dialogue skews less towards wise teacher and more towards stern disciplinarian.


Just as Bagley helped set the tone for Bendis in Ultimate Spider-Man, Kubert does the same for Millar in Ultimate X-Men. Kubert pairs well with Millar’s style. It’s very expressive and vibrant, but also has an edge to it. His aesthetic takes on a more real world approach, especially when it comes to costuming. The redesigns Kubert gave the X-Men are among some of my favourites. He updates the classic black and gold costumes for the 21st century, giving us really cool and chic individual looks that act cohesively when viewed together. While Iceman and Wolverine’s costumes are a little lackluster, the remaining X-Men look pretty snazzy. I especially appreciate the risks he took while designing Jean Grey, who is given a short pixie cut, as she is visually portrayed much differently from what we’d expect of her. Kubert is to further be commended for his composition skills, as he creates some awe-inspiring splash pages and epic action sequences. He’s additionally quite adept at inserting little quirks here and there particularly when it comes to reactions.


In terms of plot and artwork, The Tomorrow People comes pretty darn close to being a homerun. Millar and Kubert create what very well could have been the perfect basis for an introductory X-Men film. The combined threat of the Sentinels and Magneto gives the narrative that essential feeling, but it also pays homage to some of the earliest adventures the X-Men had and really modernizes them for today’s audiences. Where The Tomorrow People loses points is in its finer details. When it comes to characterization, Millar portrays certain characters in ways that makes them unlikeable and almost unrecognizable. It’s not a glaring problem (yet), but it does shift which characters I like and relate to.


RATING: A-

No comments:

Post a Comment