Review - X-Force: Assault on Graymalkin

When Cable’s abandoned ship Graymalkin is discovered floating around Earth’s orbit, S.H.I.E.L.D. and Stark Industries launch an investigation with the help of War Machine. At the same time, Cannonball leads his own expedition with members of X-Force in order to procure whatever they can that their mentor may have left behind. Given X-Force’s outlaw status, the clash between the mutants and S.H.I.E.L.D.’s task force proves to be explosive.

X-Force: Assault on Graymalkin collects X-Force #19-25 and New Warriors #31, written by Fabian Nicieza and with art by Greg Capullo.

Picking up immediately after the events of X-Cutioner’s Song, the members of X-Force is without their stalwart leader Cable and are being held captive at the X-Mansion. Cannonball convinces Xavier to led them leave and subsequently becomes the team’s new leader. While setting up their new headquarters in Camp Verde, Arizona, X-Force discovers the location of Graymalkin and teleport themselves up into space. While Cannonball and his crew contend with War Machine and S.H.I.E.L.D. agents high above the Earth, the remaining members of X-Force duke it out with the Externals. Then, Domino assembles her own ragtag band of mercenaries to take down Deadpool. For as much as Assault on Graymalkin is all about action, it’s also a collection of issues that are clearly tasked with tying up all the loose ends left by Rob Liefeld’s departure from X-Force. Truth be told, that’s not entirely a bad thing. In fact, Nicieza and Capullo prove to be a competent team that manages to elevate the quality of this book in a way that seemed nearly impossible during Liefeld’s tenure.

First and foremost, Capullo’s art is absolutely spectacular and is some of the best work from this particular era in comic books. It manages to retain the overall aesthetic of this time period, but it’s also timeless in its own way. The characters are dynamic, fresh-faced, and distinct. The action is glorious and expressive in every way imaginable. He also manages to redesign the team by giving them much more streamlined looks that aren’t quite as eyesore-ish as they were under Liefeld’s pen (Boom Boom being the exception – somehow her look worsened due to the ridiculous shoulder pads Capullo puts her in). I’m particularly a fan of the way he draws Siryn, Domino, Rictor, and Warpath. They all pop off of the page in a way that makes them all instantly recognizable.

For Nicieza’s part, he is finally able to develop the characters past being two-dimensional action figures. Most of the cast has their own unique voice and perspective, especially Cannonball, Boom Boom, and Feral. In fact, the absence of Cable gives the illusion of growth for this team and they seem more confident than ever. Story-wise, everything is very much focused on either setting things up for future issues or with concluding plot threads from previous ones. It’s not inherently bad. In fact, overall, everything is quite entertaining and engaging. Unfortunately, not a whole lot actually happens and there’s not as much development as there could have been. This is mostly due to all of the ongoing storylines, which prevented the focus from staying on X-Force. For instance, the members that get left behind on Earth when Cannonball teleports to Graymalkin don’t do a whole lot until the latter part of the arc.

X-Force: Assault on Graymalkin is infinitely more enjoyable than any singular issue from Liefeld’s brief run on the title. Capullo’s art is top notch and the quality of the writing improves greatly. It’s very much an action-oriented arc, but there’s also some growth in the characterization department. Still, Assault on Graymalkin exists in a transitory state and isn’t really the best jump on point for new readers. It all feels like it’s building towards something greater and more important.

RATING: B-

Review - X-Force Epic Collection: Under The Gun

Under the leadership of the enigmatic Cable, X-Force dedicates themselves to stopping mutant threats by any means necessary. They face off against the Mutant Liberation Front, Juggernaut, and a newly reformed Brotherhood of Mutants. Then, they must contend with betrayal after Deadpool exposes a spy within their ranks.

X-Force Epic Collection: Under The Gun collects X-Force #1-15, Annual #1, Spider-Man #16, and Wolverine #54, by Rob Liefeld, Todd McFarlane, Fabian Nicieza, and Greg Capullo.

If there’s one comic series that is viewed as being prototypical of the “extreme” nature of early-‘90s comics, it’s X-Force. Characters are dressed in shoulder pads and pockets galore, carrying guns that are disproportionately large. The excessiveness extends beyond the visuals as well. Within its first 15 issues, X-Force introduces one too many subplots and fills its pages with too many characters to keep track of. The series opens with X-Force doing battle against Juggernaut, with the help of Siryn and Spider-Man. Shortly after this, they’re attacked by the Brotherhood of Mutants and then by a task force created to bring Cable down. While all of this is going down, there’s also a side story involving the External named Gideon and his tutelage of Sunspot, Deadpool’s continued pursuit of Cable, and a flashback issue that details some of Cable’s past with his group Wild Pack. Sadly, very few of these storylines or characters have much depth. It all reads as one long toy commercial, which shouldn’t be surprising when you consider the fact that X-Force would get its own action figure line by Toy Biz. Individuals appear on page strictly to engage in action sequences and not much else. It’s not hard to believe Louise Simonson when she said, “[…]Rob really wasn't interested in the stories at all. He just wanted to do what he wanted to do, which was cool drawings of people posing in their costumes that would then sell for lots of money.”

Indeed, Rob Liefeld is the weakest link as far as contributing talent is concerned when it comes to this collection. His art is cringe-worthy and leaves me wondering how and why he was so popular to begin with. His proportions are ridiculously off in almost every panel. Men have hulking bodies with teeny tiny feet, while the women often look like they’re just a pair of floating breasts and a head (with lips that often look like swollen buttholes). His art also lacks versatility when it comes to expressiveness. Everyone looks permanently angry. Although, I suppose if I looked like a Liefeld drawing, I’d be mad all the time too. Another aspect of his style that’s always made me twitchy is that everyone looks to be in their 50s or 60s, which is odd when you consider the majority of the characters on the team are actually supposed to be either in their late teens or early twenties (Cable being the exception). Liefeld’s contributions extend beyond the art, as he’s credited with plotting as well. This undoubtedly explains why X-Force is as excessive and unfocused as it is. Bless Fabian Nicieza for trying to add some cohesion and depth to what he was given as the scripter.

Despite my harsh words for Liefeld and these early issues of X-Force, I actually see the book as a guilty pleasure. It’s so ridiculous that it’s entertaining to read. It’s a mess, but a fun one to observe. Of course, it’s not without redeeming qualities. Some of the character work is actually really engaging. Cable’s paternal dynamic with Cannonball adds layers to the team’s dynamic, while Boom Boom’s willingness to challenge authority ensures that everyone isn’t always merely following orders. Feral is an interesting character as well. True to her name, she’s unpredictable and increases the tension within the book. Siryn is another standout, though most of her growth as a character won’t occur until after Liefeld’s departure from X-Force. Story-wise, there are elements that work well. The subplot with Tolliver and Deadpool, where they expose a mole within X-Force’s ranks, is arguably the most well done. The return of the Brotherhood, this time under the direction of Toad, is also fairly enjoyable. The notion that Toad has grown out of being the snivelling sidekick to greater villains and into being a leader himself is neat, even if the overall arc itself is a bit hastily put together.

X-Force Epic Collection: Under The Gun surely qualifies as being dubbed “so bad, it’s good.” It’s overstuffed and outlandish in every possible way, but if you squint there’s a bit of heart underneath all of those damned pockets. For those who grew up in the ‘90s or may have a nostalgic obsession with this era, this collection is a perfect little nugget of trash entertainment that’s ideal for turning your brain off for a minute and just experiencing the excessiveness of it all.

RATING: C

Review - Avengers/X-Men: Bloodties

Tensions between the human and mutant populations on Genosha have reached their peak. The Avengers have been instructed to stay away from the island nation out of fear that they may interfere with attempts at diplomacy. They ignore this order for personal reasons – the daughter of the Avengers Crystal and Quicksilver has been kidnapped and taken to Genosha by the fanatical Fabian Cortez. They infiltrate Genosha and team-up with the X-Men to rescue the innocent girl caught in the crosshairs of the human-mutant conflict.

Avengers/X-Men: Bloodties collects Avengers#368-369, Avengers West Coast#101, X-Men #26, Uncanny X-Men#307 and Black Knight: Exodus #1, written by Bob Harras, Dann Thomas, Fabian Nicieza, and Scott Lobdell. It includes art by Steve Epting, Dave Ross, Andy Kubert, and John Romita Jr.

Bloodties largely builds upon storylines set in place in the X-books, such as Mutant Genesis and Fatal Attractions. A desperate Fabian Cortez has lost his place among Magneto’s Acolytes and seeks to make a name for himself by kidnapping Magneto’s human granddaughter. He’s completely unhinged and is living in fear of retribution at the hands of the immensely powerful Exodus. This places him directly in conflict with the X-Men and the Avengers, who join forces in order to stop him. Since the narrative depends so heavily on previous X-Men arcs, it feels as if the Avengers have been dropped directly into the X-Men’s world and are forced to deal with issues they otherwise would be oblivious to. They’ve long stayed away from fighting for mutants and protecting them, but here they see what their inaction has resulted in – extremism on both the human and mutant sides. Since the Avengers are an officially sanctioned organization that has to follow the orders of certain authorities, it creates an interesting contrast against the X-Men. Xavier’s mutant band of heroes are freedom fighters who are able to fight for what is right without being entangled in any bureaucratic red tape. The opposite is true of the Avengers. They’re reactive and are essentially weapons pointed at whatever big problem governments may have.

The character who stands above the rest in this crossover is Crystal. With her daughter Luna in the arms of a maniac, it is her desire to rescue Luna that drives the plot forward and gives the arc its emotional throughline. She’s portrayed as a mother unwilling to sacrifice or compromise in finding her child, which means that she has ignore the orders the Avengers have been given from the authorities and infiltrating Genosha. We get a lot of great character moments between Crystal and some of the other cast members. She and her estranged husband Quicksilver put aside their differences to work together. Furthermore, Crystal spends the bulk of her time with her sister-in-law Scarlet Witch by her side. I really love their dynamic as Wanda’s sisterly concerns and supportiveness help to counterbalance Crystal’s more frenetic state of mind. Another character that manages to steal the spotlight is Sersi. In the middle of this crossover, she has an explosive battle against Exodus. It’s intense, vibrant, and showcases just how powerful Sersi is. It’s quite possibly the most memorable scene from this arc.

The art for this crossover is surprisingly very consistent, even though there were multiple artists working on it. Steve Epting and Andy Kubert’s work is really quite similar. This provides a similar aesthetic between the Avengers’ main title and the adjectiveless X-Men book. I’m fond of their styles as it’s very streamlined and the uncomplicated nature of their pencils allows for the colours to truly pop on the page. They’re also very expressive artists and excel at capturing all kinds of emotive states. John Romita Jr. has a style all his own, but it works in tandem with Epting and Kubert’s pencils. It’s a little more sophisticated and kinetic. Romita Jr. is especially fond of doing splash pages, which can be really effective for action sequences. Dave Ross is probably the weak link of the bunch. His artwork in the pages of Avengers West Coast is passable, but feels very ‘90s. The lines aren’t as crisp and clean, while characters often look permanently angry.

The ‘90s was a decade that provided crossover after crossover for the X-Men books, many of which were overdone and overstuffed. Avengers/X-Men: Bloodties is a nice change of pace in comparison. With just five parts to it, it’s a shorter crossover and places its focus on the characters affected most by Fabian Cortez’s actions. This gives this arc a more intimate feel to it and also ensures that its personal approach to storytelling elicits sympathy and engagement from the reader. Bloodties has a lot of memorable action sequences too. The Sersi vs. Exodus brawl alone is spectacular. Crossovers between the X-Men and the Avengers are rare, so Bloodties is a really nice treat and one that fans of both teams should check out.

RATING: B+

Review - X-Men: The Road to Onslaught Volume 2

After months of imprisonment and attempted rehabilitation at the hands of Professor Xavier, Sabretooth escapes his confinement and leaves a path of destruction in his wake as he makes his way to New York City. With government forces on standby, the X-Men must track Sabretooth down before he can hurt anyone else. Then, Bishop struggles with holding onto his sanity due to reality and time hopping complications.

X-Men: The Road to Onslaught Volume 2 collects X-Men/ClanDestine #1-2, Uncanny X-Men #327-328, Annual '95, X-Men #46-49, X-Men Unlimited #9, and Sabretooth: In the Red Zone. It includes writing by Alan Davis, Larry Hama, Terry Kavanagh, Scott Lobdell, and Fabian Nicieza, as well as art by Roger Cruz, Gary Frank, Bryan Hitch, Andy Kubert, Joe Madureira, and Jeff Matsuda.

This trade reads as a compilation of largely unrelated stories, pulling both from the main X-Men titles at the same and from other books. As such, this leads to a variance in quality. The greatest example of this is the X-Men/ClanDestine two-parter that kicks off this collection. It’s a puzzling inclusion given how inaccessible it is for casual comic book readers. It features an obscure set of characters, the Destines, as they team up with the X-Men to defeat an otherworldly entity. While Alan Davis’ art in these issues is gorgeous, the storyline is random and disposable. The issue of X-Men Unlimited that was included is equally as random. It features Wolverine, Psylocke and Beast caught on a mission to the Bermuda Triangle, where they must stop the combined might of the Belasco and Bloodscream. While the story itself is penned by the talented Larry Hama, it remains an unremarkable adventure that’s further marred by subpar art.

Interestingly, one of the best stories in this trade is the one-and-done Uncanny X-Men Annual ’95. In this oversized comic, then-new X-Man Cannonball heads back home with Wolverine, Bishop, Storm, and his oldest sister in tow to investigate an anti-mutant cult that has recently recruited one of his siblings. Written by Terry Kavanagh and with art by Bryan Hitch and Bob McLeod, it’s a story that tackles zealotry and bigotry in a way that is reminiscent of the seminal God Loves, Man Kills graphic novel. The familial dynamic between Sam and his sister Paige helps to ground the story. We get a lot of great character moments with them, especially with Paige. Though more prominent in Generation X, we see references to her being ashamed of her upbringing (she tries to hide her Southern accent) and her overall drive to be a hero like Sam. Uncanny X-Men Annual ’95 may not have a whole lot to do with the arrival of Onslaught, but it remains a memorable and relevant story with some impeccable artwork.

The bulk of the material in this volume relies on and furthers the overarching plotlines that were present in the X-Men books at this time. Issues 46-47 of X-Men see Scott Lobdell and Andy Kubert tying up loose ends from way back in issues 10-11. The X-Babies have escaped the Mojoverse and a handful of the X-Men must protect them from extradimensional bounty hunters. These two issues fill readers in on what’s happened to the Mojoverse since the rebellion, which is great for Dazzler fans since she shows up towards the conclusion. Her presence (and attitude) is just about the only reason to tune in to this two-parter. Kubert’s art is sadly very inconsistent and the X-Babies are predictably rather irritating. There are some great scenes that punctuate the action, particularly between Jean Grey and Iceman. These quiet moments help to drive home how much of a family the X-Men are. Issues 48-49 are Bishop-centric, dealing primarily with what seems to be PTSD brought on by his time travels. While he’s struggling to hold on to his sanity, an assassin is sent after him. These issues deal tangentially with the aftermath of the Age of Apocalypse and attempt to give Bishop some layers, but their ugly art and dull writing really fail to leave much of a positive impression.

The other plotline that is further developed involves the continued captivity of Sabretooth. All the way back in X-Men Unlimited #3, Sabretooth willingly submitted himself for help from Professor Xavier as a means of receiving telepathic soothing that he had become addicted to. Though many X-Men disagreed with the decision, Xavier saw it as an opportunity to rehabilitate the villain. In this collection, we see the final resolution of this plotline. Sabretooth proves himself to be beyond redemption, prompting Xavier to make a deal with the government to have him incarcerated. In return, Sabretooth plots his escape from the mansion and leaves a trail of destruction in his path. Uncanny X-Men #328 is a standout issue in this saga. We get an emotionally devastated Boom Boom losing her cool once she discovers the truth about Sabretooth, as well as an intense action sequence that features a rematch between the villain and Psylocke (they pair first battled one another way back in Uncanny X-Men #213). It’s also worth noting that the issue is illustrated by Joe Madureira at the height of his popularity. His manga-influenced style is beautiful and dynamic. His Psylocke is especially iconic. Sabretooth: In the Red Zone concludes this arc. The original X-Men are sent by Xavier to apprehend Sabretooth, which gives us some great scenes of the O5 working together as a team. The synergy that they have is really electric, so it’s not hard to understand why this formation is so popular amongst fans. The combination of Fabian Nicieza’s dialogue and Gary Frank’s near-flawless art makes this issue incredibly cinematic. So much so, that it would make for a great animated film.

X-Men: The Road to Onslaught Volume 2 is really not worth the price of admission. It’s great for completionists and X-Men fans who loved the ‘90s, especially since it has a lot of cool extras. There are reprints of trading cards, for example, that are included after each issue. Uncanny X-Men Annual ’95 is a great read, as is the one-two punch of Uncanny X-Men #328 and Sabretooth: In the Red Zone. The writing on those issues is impeccable, but the art is even more impressive (arguably some of the best that Hitch, Madureira and Frank have done). Unfortunately, the rest of what is collected here is pretty forgettable. It’s probably better to buy some of the individual issues via Comixology than shell out the money for this hefty trade.

RATING: B- (buoyed mostly by the high quality of some of the issues included)

Review: X-Men - The Road to Onslaught Volume 1

The X-Men have been pulled into the ruthless machinations of the mutant terrorist group Gene Nation, whose leader Marrow has a decades-long grudge against Storm. Marrow intends to make Storm suffer for the neglect she felt when the X-Man led the Morlocks. Then, Rogue and Iceman go on a roadtrip to escape from the drama that surrounds their lives as X-Men. Their departure may prove to be ill-timed as a shadowy villain known as Onslaught seems to be closing in on the X-Men.

X-Men: The Road to Onslaught Volume 1 collects X-Men Prime #1, Uncanny X-Men #322-326, X-Men #42-45, Annual '95, and X-Men Unlimited #8, written primarily by Scott Lobdell and Fabian Nicieza with art by Roger Cruz, Terry Dodson, Bryan Hitch, Joe Madureira and more!

This collection pulls stories from a transitionary period of the X-Men books between the critically-acclaimed Age of Apocalypse and the companywide crossover Onslaught. As such, it shouldn’t be a surprise that the majority of the issues here are stuck between dealing with the aftermath of the former and setting up the latter. This creates an inconsistent tone that constantly shifts the narrative focus, leaving the reader with the sense that there doesn’t seem to be a whole lot of movement forward with the storylines being presented. For the most part, the issues that deal with the set-up of Onslaught are far more interesting than those that pull in some of the forgettable baddies from AoA (Dark Riders, I’m looking at you guys).

The writers tread a lot of water here as they place more of an emphasis on the interpersonal dramas between their characters than on action. For example, we’re treated to a date between Psylocke and Archangel and suffer through the continued melodrama of Rogue and Gambit’s tenuous relationship. Admittedly, I find the then-budding romance between Psylocke and Archangel to breathe new life into both characters. It helps to lighten Warren’s personality after being depicted in a grimmer manner following his transformation into Death at the hands of Apocalypse, while Psylocke gets to act as something other than just the team’s T&A. The drama between Rogue and Gambit is more contrived. The issues collected here occur after an incident where Rogue kissed Gambit, which ultimately left him in a coma and her with his memories. She’s thus left the X-Men and is travelling westward with Iceman in tow. This subplot is really engrossing, particularly as we get to see two characters that had previously never interacted much bond on a good ol’ roadtrip. Although, Rogue’s behaviour puts a damper on the two becoming overly close as she seems eager to remain closed off to all those around her. She is also contemptuous towards Gambit and remains judgmental over his past, which ultimately makes her look like a big flaming hypocrite given the fact that we know she’s no saint either (which both Carol Danvers and Dazzler can attest to). However, her icy rejection of Gambit does lead towards a touching scene with Storm consoling Gambit.

While a fair share of the stories in this collection read more as supplementary rather than essential, there are a few noteworthy issues that are worth discussing. Uncanny X-Men #322 sees Beast, Bishop and Psylocke going up against the Juggernaut, who is the first to reveal the coming of Onslaught. Uncanny X-Men #323-325 deals with Marrow and Gene Nation. This three-parter serves as a conclusion to a culmination of events that date back all the way to when Storm won leadership of the Morlocks from Callisto. Storm’s subsequent neglect of the Morlocks, the Marauder’s massacre, and Mikhail Rasputin’s teleportation of them into another plane laid down the groundwork for Marrow’s hatred towards humans and the X-Men. She returns in these issues to enact her revenge, but instead she finds herself up against Storm’s legendary will and ultimately underestimates her opponent. Finally, X-Men Prime is a beautifully poignant series of vignettes written by Lobdell and Nicieza with the help of roughly half a dozen of the decade’s most talented artists. Though it is a transitionary issue meant to wrap up the remaining threads of Age of Apocalypse, it is grounded by an incredibly (and depressingly) relevant story of a mutant who is viciously attacked by a group of humans while he is mere miles away from seeking refuge within the hallowed walls of the Xavier Institute.

X-Men: The Road to Onslaught Volume 1 is pretty much what you’d expect from a collection of comics from the middle of the 1990s. With significantly fewer pockets and shoulderpads than its early-‘90s predecessors, these issues are gorgeously illustrated by some of the best artists in the industry at that point. Those penciled by Joe Madureira are especially memorable. Amidst the many forgettable villains presented here, Lobdell and Nicieza make up for lackluster storylines with excellent dialogue and themes that remain relevant to today’s intolerant society. I’m especially left impressed by how multi-dimensional and dynamic the women they write are. Storm, Jean Grey, Rogue, Psylocke, Callisto, Trish Tilby, and even Marrow are all easily the most memorable characters in this collection. Colossus, Gambit and Beast also have their moments. If anything, The Road to Onslaught Volume 1 is perfect for fans of these characters (especially if you love Rogue and/or Gambit).

RATING: B-