Review - Birds of Prey: Of Like Minds

When Black Canary is kidnapped during a mission gone awry, she is used as leverage in an attempt to get Oracle to divulge one of the most precious secrets in the world. Canary’s captor – the handsome yet dangerous Savant – wants the hacker supreme to tell him what Batman’s true identity is or he will kill her partner. With time running out and Savant’s patience wearing thin, Oracle enlists the help of the unpredictable Huntress to find and rescue Black Canary before she is executed.

Birds of Prey: Of Like Minds collects Birds of Prey #56-61, written by Gail Simone and illustrated by Ed Benes.

As the introductory arc to Gail Simone’s seminal run on Birds of Prey, Of Like Minds is a tense and tightly crafted story that is entirely character-driven. It begins with Black Canary in the middle of a mission. After Oracle gains intel that a CEO is intending to cheat his employees out of their retirement funds, she assigns Black Canary to scare him straight. Everything appears to go well until the target goes home and sends suicidal messages to Oracle. Before Oracle can talk him down, Black Canary goes to his house to intervene. When she arrives, she discovers that the whole thing was a set-up. She is attacked by the criminal Savant and his assistant Creote, then held hostage at another location. This initiates an anxious tête-à-tête between Savant and Oracle as the pair negotiate for what they want – Batman’s secret identity and Canary’s safe release, respectively. Unwilling to give away such an important secret, Oracle recruits Huntress to save Canary from Savant’s clutches.

Despite the simple set-up, this story arc is absolutely gripping. Simone has such a firm grasp on who these characters are and teases out their personalities in a way that makes them very palpable to readers. Black Canary and Oracle are presented as near polar opposites. The former is impulsive and thinks with her heart, while the latter is methodical and incredibly rational. This causes friction, particularly in the aftermath of Canary’s capture, as Oracle fears that her partner’s rashness could get her killed. The reason this is such a riveting conflict is not simply because these characters are opposites, but because of how much they love one another. This sense of sisterhood permeates this arc (and the rest of Simone’s run) and makes Canary’s captivity that much more distressing. Of course, while the situation may be distressing, our girl Canary is never a damsel in distress. Unlike in Green Arrow: The Longbow Hunters, her kidnapping is intended as motivation for the male character. Here, Canary is actively working towards rescuing herself by manipulating her captors and slowly freeing herself from her bonds. Simone makes it very clear that Canary is not a passive victim.

While there’s a lot of strong character work done on Black Canary and Oracle (and the villain Savant), the true standout for me was Huntress. I absolutely love her voice as a character. Her dialogue drips with sarcasm and wit, while her unpredictable nature makes her an incredibly dynamic and engaging heroine. The banter between Canary and Huntress is especially hilarious. The way they playfully make fun of one another is really cute and displays a certain level of comfort between them. She isn’t all sass either. There’s a lot of heart behind her stomach-less outfit. Simone does something really neat with Huntress’ introduction that really shows the vulnerability of the character. When Oracle contacts Huntress, she’s tracking down a kidnapped baby. Oracle helps her out and Huntress successfully rescues the baby. We get an adorable scene where Huntress takes off her glove and gives it to the baby to play with. It’s a seemingly innocuous moment, but it shows her soft spot for kids. We see a lot of her tenacity as well. Huntress is not the most skilled fighter, a fact even Canary points out, but she’s unwilling to admit defeat and won’t give up until Canary is safe. She’s a boss.

Ed Benes’ art is really stunning. His characters are absolutely gorgeous – men and women alike. I like the slight anime influence to his work and the effort he puts into musculature, facial expressions, and hairstyles. He also really knows how to draw fantastic action sequences (of which there are a few rather memorable ones in this collection). In fact, his art from this arc has become so ingrained within me that those images still pop up in my head when I think of the Birds. However, his art is not without its flaws. The women all seem to have the same face, there’s some awkward perspective here and there, and there are some strange things about characters’ anatomy (Black Canary’s torso seems overly long and her waist far too thin). Aside from that, Benes’ work is also known for its cheesecake-like quality. There are a lot of butt shots and we see Canary’s derriere hanging out of her costume a little too often.

Of all the comic book runs I’ve read (and re-read!), very few fill me with joyful exuberance quite like Gail Simone’s Birds of Prey tenure. Her opening arc is clever, emotional, and filled with a lot of fantastic character moments. Simone really knows how to make you love the characters she writes by giving readers electric dialogue and relatable interpersonal interactions. Ed Benes makes for a great creative partner for Simone (despite his T&A tendencies) as his attractive and vibrant art really enhances the story. Birds of Prey: Of Like Minds is a stellar read and is an essential trade for anyone’s collection.

RATING: A